Where is Caputo's Pizza located?

Caputo's Pizza is at 36 James Street, Middletown, NY.

What are Caputo's Pizza's hours?

Hours aren't listed publicly. Contact Caputo's Pizza to confirm before you go.

How do I contact Caputo's Pizza?

Claim the listing to add contact details.

What should I look for in a restaurant in Middletown?

Peak hours tell you the most about a restaurant — a quick call about wait times on a Friday night answers more than any listing can. Checking hours and confirming details directly with the business is always worth the two minutes.

restaurant · Middletown, NY

Caputo's Pizza

Name: Caputo's Pizza
Address: 36 James Street, Middletown, NY

restaurant in Middletown, NY

restaurant near Middletown, NY

Written & reviewed by Robert BibbFounder, SEO Local · Generative Engine Optimization · 22 years in SEO · Updated October 2026 · LinkedIn

No website yet?We’ll build you one — $299Pure agentic: designed, written & launched for you. See what’s included →

36 James Street
Middletown, NY

Cuisine: pizza

Looking for a restaurant in Middletown? Caputo's Pizza is listed here. The menu centers on pizza cooking. Middletown was the main station along the Erie Railroad mainline in the city of Middletown, New York. It's located at 36 James Street. The First Congregational Church of Middletown, New York, United States is one of the most visible landmarks of that city's downtown skyline. Other restaurants nearby include Alondra's (0.1 mi) and Taiwan Way (0.2 mi). It sits in central Middletown, at 41.4464° N, 74.4213° W. On top of that, the Paramount Theatre is a historic theater located at 17 South Street in Middletown, New York, United States.

Caputo's Pizza is a restaurant at 36 James Street in Middletown, NY. It's known for pizza.

It is one of 48 restaurants listed for Middletown. 20 of them sit within about a mile, close enough to compare in one trip. If dietary needs matter at your table, it is worth asking how the kitchen handles gluten-free or allergy requests before you go. Close alternatives include Alondra's (less than 0.1 mi), Taiwan Way (0.2 mi), and Elsie's Luncheonette (0.3 mi).

The median household income in Orange County is about $96,497. Orange County has roughly 137,311 households. The median home value in Orange County is around $361,100. Orange County is home to roughly 403,840 people. The Paramount Theatre is a historic theater located at 17 South Street in Middletown, New York, United States. The First Congregational Church of Middletown, New York, United States is one of the most visible landmarks of that city's downtown skyline. Summers in Middletown average near 81°F and winters settle around 24°F. Contact Caputo's Pizza to confirm current details. Caputo's Pizza appears here from public listings. Claim the page to keep hours, services, and booking details current.

Frequently asked questions

Where is Caputo's Pizza located?: Caputo's Pizza is at 36 James Street, Middletown, NY.
What are Caputo's Pizza's hours?: Hours aren't listed publicly. Contact Caputo's Pizza to confirm before you go.
What other restaurants are near Caputo's Pizza?: Nearby restaurants include Alondra's (less than 0.1 mi), Taiwan Way (0.2 mi), and Elsie's Luncheonette (0.3 mi).
How do I contact Caputo's Pizza?: Claim the listing to add contact details.
What should I look for in a restaurant in Middletown?: Peak hours tell you the most about a restaurant — a quick call about wait times on a Friday night answers more than any listing can. Checking hours and confirming details directly with the business is always worth the two minutes.

Own Caputo's Pizza? Claim your free listing

This is your live restaurant page in Middletown, NY. Claim it in a couple of minutes and turn it into a real growth engine — no cost to start.

Customer leads straight to your inboxVisitors can message you right from this page and it lands in your email with their details and where it came from. Claim to add a booking form and reply as the verified owner.
A free dofollow backlinkYour listing links to your site rel="nofollow" until you claim it. Claim it and the link flips to dofollow — a real backlink from hashtag.org that passes authority in Ahrefs & SEMrush.
5 free keyword phrasesStake 5 keyword phrases free on the open network the moment you claim your #name, so you start ranking for the exact terms your customers search — no ad budget.
20 real business backlink partners for lifeJoin the BRON backlink network and get 20 links from real, related businesses — permanent partner backlinks that keep compounding your domain authority.

Claim Caputo's Pizza How claiming works